Table of Contents
A good boutique flatpick has run about $40 to $45 for years, which is why so many players stay with a bag of Delrin picks and wonder what they're missing. Token picks start at $22 for the Amber and top out at $35 for the Green, so the question gets easier to answer: is a US-made, machine-beveled pick worth a little more than lunch, and which of the three materials should you start with? Token picks are new to the market, so here's what we know, what we hear from players, and the one thing nobody can tell you yet.
What Are Token Picks?
Token picks are flatpicks made by Token Made, a California company that launched them in September 2025. They're 100 percent US made, from the resin powders to the final machining, and every pick is individually CNC machined rather than hand beveled. The shape and the speed bevel are designed in software and cut with Token's own tooling.
That matters for one practical reason: the backup pick in your case feels like the one in your hand. Hand-beveled picks can vary a little from one to the next, and if you've ever lost a favorite and found that its replacement didn't feel the same, you know why consistency is worth paying for. Andy Falco of the Infamous Stringdusters plays a Token, and that's the first thing he brings up:
"These picks are just made with absolute precision, and the consistency that they're made [with], because they're machine cut on CNC." Andy Falco
How to read a Token pick code
Every pick carries a code like A3-55, and once you know the system you can shop the whole wall without opening a bag:
- The letter is the shape: A is the Large Triangle, B the Small Triangle, C the Two Round, D the All Round and F the Teardrop.
- The first number is the material: 1 is Amber, 2 is Tan, 3 is Green and 4 is Black Amber.
- The last number is the thickness in thousandths of an inch: 50 is 1.27mm, 55 is 1.40mm and 60 is 1.52mm, with thinner Teardrops down to 0.9mm.
So an A3-55 is a Large Triangle in Green at 1.40mm, and a C1-60 is a Two Round in Amber at 1.52mm.
Token A3-55 GREEN Flatpick - Large Triangle 1.40mm
$35.00
The Token Green Flatpick brings together cutting-edge material science and precision craftsmanship for players who want durability, volume, and a perfectly balanced response. Made from Green “No. 3,” a Token Made exclusive created through a proprietary process using a unique… Learn more...
Which Token Picks Material Should You Choose?
The material is the real decision, because it sets the price and most of the tone. The descriptions below are Token's, and the prices are ours today. If you'd rather hear the difference than read about it, our short demo plays all three materials back to back:
| Material | What it is | How Token describes it | Our price |
|---|---|---|---|
| Amber (No. 1) | Translucent virgin PEI | Balanced, with a focused edge and a soft feel in the hand | $22 |
| Black Amber (No. 4) | Machined, tumbled to a satin finish | Tone, clarity and volume (Teardrop shape only) | $24 |
| Tan (No. 2) | Virgin PEEK | Warm and balanced, buttery feel, holds its stiffness | $26 |
| Green (No. 3) | Token's own polyamide-imide | Not too bright, not too dark, with surprising volume | $35 |
Amber is the place to start if you've never spent real money on a pick. It's the least expensive Token, and PEI is a material pick makers have used for a long time, so it's a fair first step up from Delrin without much risk.
Tan is for the player who digs in hard and wants a pick that stays the same shape. PEEK is known for wear resistance, and the low-friction surface is what Token means by a buttery feel: the pick slides off the string instead of catching on it.
Green costs the most, and Token makes the material itself. It's the one to try if you want volume from a pick that doesn't sound brittle, which is what the "not too bright, not too dark" line is getting at.
Token B2-55 TAN Flatpick - Small Triangle 1.40mm
$26.00
The Token Tan Flatpick is built for players who want strength, longevity, and a tone that feels as smooth as it sounds. Made from Tan “No. 2” virgin polyetheretherketone, this pick offers outstanding mechanical properties, maintaining its stiffness and structural… Learn more...
Which Shape Fits Your Playing?
Shape is personal, but the choice usually comes down to where you play and what you've played before:
- Large Triangle (A): the bluegrass guitar standard. Three playing corners, plenty to hold onto, and a stable feel when you're driving rhythm.
- Small Triangle (B): more compact, for players who want speed and articulation on single-note runs.
- Two Round (C): designed with mandolin players in mind. Use the point for a crisp attack and roll to the rounded edge for a warmer, fatter tone, which makes it a good pick for players who switch between mandolin and guitar.
- All Round (D): rounded all the way around, for a softer edge on the attack.
- Teardrop (F): the familiar shape for players coming from a standard pick, and the only shape offered in the thinner gauges.
Thickness matters as much as shape. Andy Falco's take is a good reason to try a heavier gauge than you'd expect:
"I could even use a heavier gauge pick, so I get the benefit of the heavier pick tone but not feeling the drag on my hand." Andy Falco
If you play mandolin, our mandolin picks page has the other boutique options to compare against, and our guitar pick guide on thickness, material and shape goes deeper on how each one changes your tone.
Token C1-60 AMBER Flatpick - Two Round 1.52mm
$22.00
The Token Amber Flatpick is crafted for players who demand clarity, durability, and a confident, articulate attack. Made from Amber “No. 1” translucent virgin polyetherimide, a material long respected in the pick industry, it delivers a beautifully balanced tone with… Learn more...
Are Token Picks Worth the Money?
We've made the case for boutique picks before, and it holds for Token picks too. The first argument is that you don't have to be a pro to hear it. Students who finally buy a good pick come back saying they can hear and feel the difference, and the difference shows up most when they go back to their old pick after a few hours.
"The amateur beginner player will hear and feel that difference as much as a professional player."
The second argument is feel. A worn Delrin pick fights the string, and a good boutique pick gets out of the way. "When I play with this, it's like it's an extension of my hand," is how we put it when we compared two boutique brands in our BlueChip vs ToneSlabs blind test.
The third is cost over time. A plastic pick can wear out of shape in an evening, and a good boutique pick lasts for years if you don't lose it. Spread over that much playing, $22 to $35 is a small expense, less than a couple of sets of strings. Our acoustic guitar strings guide covers the other half of that equation.
The Catch with Token Picks
Token picks have been on the market since September 2025, so nobody, including us, has had one for five years. That's the honest gap. The boutique picks we've praised for longevity earned that reputation over a decade of players wearing them down, and Token hasn't had the time yet. The materials are known for wear resistance, but how a Token holds up after years of hard flatpicking is something we'll only know by playing them.
The other catch is stock. Green is the hardest to find right now: several Green shapes and gauges are sold out as we write this, so if you want a specific Green, check the Token picks collection before you settle on it, or try the same shape in Tan.
Who Should Buy Token Picks
- The Delrin player who's curious: start with an Amber in the shape you already use. At $22 it's the cheapest way into a machine-beveled pick.
- The hard-driving rhythm player: a Tan or Green Large Triangle at 1.40mm or 1.52mm.
- The mandolin player, or anyone who switches: the Two Round, in whichever material fits your budget.
- The player who wants proof first: a pick with a long track record may suit you better for now. Our BlueChip vs ToneSlabs test is a good place to start.
A pick is the easiest upgrade in the shop, but it can only pull out what the guitar has. Every guitar we sell gets our 23-Point Professional Inspection before it ships, so the instrument is playing its best when your new pick meets it. Browse our acoustic guitars or come try a few Tokens at the counter in Springfield.
Related reading
Ready to try one? Shop every Token pick we have in stock, or browse all of our flatpicks.
